Sunday, November 22, 2026

The Murder of Dallas Patrolman J.D. Tippit

Revisionists Promote the Unbelievable and Unprovable as Truth

FIG. 1 – "With Malice" (2013), Officer J.D. Tippit, and Tippit's badge. Credit: Dale K. Myers Collection
 
BY DALE K. MYERS

What can you say about a murdered public servant? That he loved the music of Bob Wills and the Texas Playboys, Clark Gable movies, bushy Christmas trees, sleeping in, and clowning around with family and friends?
 
More than sixty-years after his death, those who knew and loved the boy from Clarksville, Texas, still grieve. His murder ripped away the remaining pages of his life, leaving a wound so deep and so painful that those who shook hands with him could not even talk about it.
 
After his funeral, the newspaper stories about his shocking death faded. The few pictures that family and friends had in photo albums were carefully preserved and life went on – without him.
 
No doubt
 
In those early years, there was no doubt who was responsible for J.D. Tippit’s death. The story of his encounter with a young man on Tenth Street in Oak Cliff, although somewhat confused in the initial reports, was quickly sorted out and verified by a posse of diligent local reporters and published in newspapers nationwide.
 
The Warren Commission, backed largely by an FBI investigation, pronounced what everyone already knew was true – Lee Harvey Oswald, in the wake of the assassination of President John F. Kennedy, shot Officer Tippit in broad daylight in front of multiple witnesses, then fled to the nearby Texas Theater where he was apprehended with the murder weapon in his hand. 
 
Oswald’s precise motive for the murder was obliterated by nightclub owner Jack Ruby, two days later, when Ruby decided to dish out his own brand of justice. Few in law enforcement thought that Oswald’s motive was unclear in the Tippit killing, given his flight from the Texas School Book Depository where police found his Mannlicher-Carcano rifle, suspected and later proven to have been the murder weapon in the JFK assassination. You didn’t have to draw a picture for any seasoned lawman. The Dallas police instantly knew the significance of the evidence and why it explained Oswald’s murderous act on Tenth Street.
 
Enter the critics
 
A few months after Tippit’s murder, a group of radical-left critics – Mark Lane, Joachim Joesten, Thomas Buchanan and others – began to pontificate on the case in an effort to cast doubt on the obvious guilt of young Oswald. Their efforts were largely relegated to tabloid-style newspapers and left-wing publications; and so, they were largely ignored by the mainstream press.
 
But the voices grew louder and those who knew little to nothing of the true facts began to repeat what the voices of dissent were preaching.
 
The local Dallas press, who covered the Tippit story in real time and knew the participants personally, paid no attention to the vulgar accusations being made about Dallas law enforcement, the Dallas press themselves, and the victim in the story, Officer J.D. Tippit.
 
By 1975, twelve-years after the murder, the voices of dissent had grown so loud that the call for a second government investigation was demanded.
 
Three-years later, the House Select Committee on Assassination (HSCA) raked over the same coals the Warren Commission had left smoldering. When it came to the Tippit murder, the HSCA’s conclusion was the same as the Warren Commission: Lee Harvey Oswald was responsible for the murder that snatched the life of Officer Tippit on Tenth Street.
 
Technology deals a hand
 
For a brief period, the matter was laid to rest. Then came a technological marvel – the Internet. It promised to provide an avenue for easy sharing and discussion of ideas. While text-based at first, it quickly evolved into a gateway for sharing photographs, moving images, audio and ideas – all instantly and on a global scale!
 
Unfortunately, not all ideas carry equally weight. The power of a relatively few talking-heads on three or four television channels morphed into millions of mouths talking over each other on millions of podcast “channels” and websites. Most had nothing to say of any real value, but it didn’t matter. They had a global audience, with no checks or balances.
 
The result? Disaster for anyone interested in the truth, now buried in an avalanche of misdirection and misinformation. For the newcomer to any subject, but particularly the JFK assassination and the murder of Officer J.D. Tippit, the question of the digital age rears its ugly head – What is truth?
 
The old-timers can spot the frauds instantly; no problem. But the young and naïve, God help them, are stuck in a morass of lies and deception that’s tough to navigate without some sort of guide.
 
The investigative file
 
I’m one of those old-timers. Long before the Internet, I was already sick-and-tired of trying to determine what was true and what was not as I dug through the writings and research of the early left-wing radical critics. It never occurred to me that they were driven by their radical ideology and that I should double-check everything I was reading. That’s how naïve I was when I started. Suffice it to say, I’ve learned a great deal since then.
 
After catching Mark Lane distorting the truth in his landmark book, Rush to Judgment, I set out to compile an investigative file on the Tippit murder from the ground up – warts and all. Instead of asking questions that had already been asked and left unanswered by the critics, I decided to see if I could find the answers, while those who were involved in the original reporting and investigating were still alive.
 
It took me ten-years to assemble the definitive investigative file on the Tippit murder; the file that was never created due to Oswald’s untimely death at the hands of Jack Ruby. Along the way, as I looked under every rock, I slowly changed my mind about the Tippit shooting.
 
Early on, influenced by the radical-left writings I had been exposed to, I suspected that Oswald might be innocent of the Tippit shooting. But after much due diligence, I discovered what should have been obvious from the start – Oswald was guilty of Tippit’s murder, not just beyond a reasonable doubt, but beyond any and all doubt.
 
I had been snookered, like so many, by so-called “researchers” who hadn’t done any real research at all. They were very good and piling up the supposition, innuendo and guess-work; but very bad at actually finding real evidence to support their claims. In fact, most of their accusations were made up out of whole cloth.
 
So, I wrote With Malice: Lee Harvey Oswald and the Murder of Officer J.D. Tippit (Oak Cliff Press, 1998; revised in 2013), the definitive look at the Tippit murder. I didn’t set out to write a book, but I was compelled to publish what I unearthed for the benefit of those who, like me, were only interested in the truth, whatever it might be.
 
A new breed of revisionists
 
More than sixty-years after the events of November 22, 1963, the radical-left revisionists continue to push the narrative that Dallas Patrolman J.D. Tippit was part of a plot to murder Kennedy or rub-out Lee Harvey Oswald, the accused presidential assassin.
 
They rarely acknowledge my 1998 book (or its 2013 update) or any of my blog articles, though they don’t have a problem lifting facts I uncovered and published for the first time, without credit, of course. I’ve come to accept that it’s all part of the conspiracy community’s territory.
 
More disturbing is the current trend to float conspiracy-ladened tales, woven from a small bit of fact and a large bolt of fantasy, and get a consensus of support before committing to the narrative. Does no one have the courage to carve their words in stone without peer approval? 
 
These made-up narratives are usually loaded down with endless bloviation to explain how it is reasonable and sensible to accept as truth, although it’s clear from the pages and pages of explanation that the even the proponents have a hard time accepting their own narrative as believable.
 
We’ve heard it all before
 
The current breed of revisionists has cast Tippit as a co-conspirator seeking to hunt down and murder Oswald (supposedly, Tippit’s actions backfired and he got killed) and Oswald as an innocent victim, who would easily have been exonerated by an “innocent project” investigation.
 
But we’ve heard all this malarky before. The names of those pushing for Oswald’s innocence have changed since the early days, but the idea of keeping the conspiracy pot simmering with lies and distortions remains exactly the same.
 
In fact, it’s become so bizarre, that the conspiracy mongers have resorted to claiming that everything we thought we knew about the murder of Officer Tippit is – in fact – wrong! Eye witnesses didn't see what they said they saw, law enforcement lied about everything, and the media went along for the ride.
 
So, what really happened? They don’t know. They certainly aren’t able to offer a coherent narrative that would even satisfy Inspector Clouseau, or they would have written one by now. Instead, we get one insane narrative after another, each equally devoid of any known facts – just lots of supposition, innuendo and self-absorbed clairvoyance.
 
The solution to the “great mystery”, as the revisionists have dubbed it, is really quite simple.
 
The chronology of history
 
History unfolds in a linear manner. This is a death knell to the revisionists, who must separate the why from the what in order to push the narrative in the direction they choose.
 
However, if you simply view the events of November 22, 1963 in chronological order, the “why” becomes self-evident; a cage from which no revisionist can escape. As an example, look at what Oswald did after the assassination.
 
Oswald’s actions
 
As hundreds of nearby spectators poured into Dealey Plaza in the wake of the Kennedy assassination (a natural thing to do), Oswald left the area.
 
In his wake, police discovered three spent shells on the sixth-floor of the Texas School Book Depository, fired from a rifle that Oswald ordered under the alias A.J. Hidell back in March, 1963.
 
Oswald caught the first bus that came down Elm Street (Marsalis line), rather than wait for his usual bus (Beckley line) that would have dropped him in front of his rooming house.
 
When the bus got caught up in traffic, backing up from the assassination scene, Oswald requested a bus transfer (presumably to use later), departed the bus and caught a cab in front of the Greyhound Bus Station a few blocks south.
 
Oswald told the cab driver to take him to the 500 block on North Beckley, but had the cab driver let him out in the 700 block (two blocks earlier). The address Oswald gave (500 block) forced the cab driver to drive past Oswald’s rooming house.
 
Oswald left the cab and doubled-back to 1026 N. Beckley, site of his rented room. Oswald entered in a hurry (noticed by housekeeper Earlene Roberts), went to his room, armed himself with a Smith & Wesson revolver (which Oswald later freely admitted), and emerged a short time later zipping up a “short gray coat” as he hurried out the front door. A moment later, Mrs. Roberts saw him standing at the curb near a bus stop in front of the rooming house. She didn’t pay any attention to what Oswald did next.
 
All of those actions happened in the first 30-minutes following the assassination. Police would later describe Oswald’s actions as those of a “man in flight”. You can see their point. Oswald leaving the scene of the presidential shooting, considering his political astuteness, certainly looks suspicious. Oswald grabbing the first bus (inconvenient for his destination) is also highly suspicious. Catching a cab is extremely suspicious given Oswald’s frugality and relentless use of public transportation. (In fact, it would be akin to most people unexpectedly taking a limousine home from work.) Not having the cab driver take him to his rented room in the 1000-block, but instead giving the cabbie a 500-block location is deceptive and highly suspicious, given the circumstances.
 
Approximately 13 minutes after being seen in front of the 1026 N. Beckley rooming house, Oswald was identified as the person who shot Dallas Patrolman J.D. Tippit at Tenth and Patton. The shooting location was about two blocks from the only bus stop where the bus transfer Oswald obtained earlier was good. (He could have used the transfer to take him south out of the city.)
 
Eleven eyewitnesses tracked Oswald as he fled west from the Tippit shooting scene. He was last seen cutting through the parking lot behind a Texaco service station two blocks from where Tippit lay dead.
 
Police poured into the area in search of the cop-killer. They found a “short gray” jacket ditched in the parking lot. Police were directed to the Oak Cliff Public Library where the “suspect” was reported to be. Police surrounded the library, but the “suspect” turned out to be a young man who worked at the library.
 
Six blocks west of the Tippit shooting scene, Hardy Shoe Store manager Johnny Brewer saw Oswald step into the vestibule, jacketless, shirt-tail out, his hair disheveled. He kept looking over his shoulder at police cars, their sirens blaring, as they responded to the “suspect” at the Oak Cliff Public Library.
 
When Oswald stepped out of the vestibule and continued up the street, Brewer stepped out onto the sidewalk. He could see Julia Postal, the ticker-taker at the Texas Theater. She was out of her booth and was standing at the curb looking westward, up the street. Brewer could see Oswald too, as he slipped into the theater behind Postal’s back. Brewer walked up the street and alerted Postal to the fact that Oswald had snuck into the theater. He explained that Oswald was acting suspicious in front of his shoe store and suggested that he (Oswald) may be who the police were looking for.
 
After checking theater briefly to see if Oswald had gone out the back, and satisfied that Oswald was still in the theater (even though he hadn’t seen him), Brewer returned to the ticket-booth and urged Postal to telephone the police. She did.
 
Police arrived in force, entering the front of the theater. Brewer, stationed behind the exit curtains near the front-left side of the screen, saw Oswald sitting near the back when the house lights came up. Oswald, seated in the fifth seat from the aisle, third row from the back, stood up, stepped to the aisle (as if to leave), then sat back down in the third seat from the aisle, same row as before.
 
Brewer heard police rattling the backdoor behind him. He let police in and pointed out Oswald as the man he thought was suspicious. Dallas Patrolman M.N. “Nick” McDonald approached Oswald from the aisle he was sitting closest to. Three other patrolmen were shadowing McDonald, moving toward Oswald from the opposite aisle. 
 
When McDonald reached Oswald, he ordered him to his feet. Oswald stood up and raised his hands shoulder high (without being asked). McDonald heard him say, “This is it. It’s all over now.” McDonald reached down from Oswald’s waist to frisk him, when Oswald suddenly punched McDonald in the face, knocking him down into the seats. McDonald hollered, “I’ve got him!” as the three other patrolmen closed in from Oswald’s left. As McDonald yelled, Oswald reached into his waist band and pulled out his Smith and Wesson revolver. McDonald instinctively grabbed the cylinder to keep it from turning as Oswald attempted to fire a shot. Police wrestled the gun away from Oswald and he was handcuffed.
 
Oswald began yelling, “Police brutality! I am not resisting arrest!”
 
Oswald was hustled out the front door to a waiting unmarked police car. A crowd of jeering spectators surrounded them. Many thought Oswald was being arrested as the presidential assassin, unaware that a patrolman had been killed six blocks east. Several in the crowd broke through the police cordon and tried to get to Oswald as he was stuffed into the back of the squad car and driven off to police headquarters.
 
When arresting officers got the suspect to police headquarters downtown, the significance of their prisoner quickly came into sharp focus.
 
The suspected cop-killer, Lee Harvey Oswald, was a 24-year-old employee of the Texas School Book Depository who had left the building within minutes of the presidential assassination. At that instant, Oswald became the prime suspect in the assassination.
 
In order to hold Oswald in custody long enough to give them time to investigate his possible connection to the Kennedy assassination, police focused on gathering evidence in the Tippit shooting.
 
Three lineups were held Friday evening. The first one, viewed by Helen Markham at 4:30 p.m., convinced police they had the right suspect in Tippit’s murder. After the second line-up, held at 6:30 p.m. (viewed by Ted Callaway, Sam Guinyard and bus driver Cecil McWatters), Oswald was charged with the Tippit murder. The charge allowed police to hold Oswald, as they gathered evidence in the JFK assassination. A third line-up was held at 7:55 p.m. (viewed by sister-in-law’s Barbara and Virginia Davis, and Howard L. Brennan).
 
Markham, Callaway, Guinyard, and the Davis girls all identified Oswald as the man they saw shoot the Dallas patrolman or who was seen fleeing the immediate vicinity. In the coming weeks, eleven witnesses identified Oswald as the person responsible for Tippit’s death.
 
Four spent shells recovered at the Tippit murder scene were later proven to have been fired from Oswald’s revolver, the same firearm he admitted taking to the Texas Theater where arresting officers ripped it from his hand.
 
The light-gray zipper jacket found on a parking lot two blocks from the Tippit murder scene contained fibers matching the color and microscopic characteristics of the shirt Oswald was wearing when he was arrested. According to FBI lab technicians, the fibers couldn’t be matched to Oswald’s specific shirt, but they did come from either Oswald’s shirt or one exactly like it; further evidence that Oswald was indeed Tippit’s killer.
 
Marina Oswald later told investigators that her husband owned only two jackets – the light-gray jacket found in the parking lot two blocks from the Tippit murder scene and a dark blue jacket which was discovered in a first-floor lunchroom at the Texas School Book Depository two weeks after the assassination.
 
More evidence of guilt in the assassination
 
The Dallas police later discovered that before leaving Ruth Paine’s house in Irving on the morning of the assassination, Oswald had left behind his wedding ring and $170 ($1,871.89 today) in cash. Oswald kept a little over $13.87 dollars ($152.72 today) for himself.
 
As Oswald approached Buell Frazier’s house for the ride back into Dallas, Frazier’s sister, Linnie Mae Randle, saw Oswald carrying a long package.
 
Before climbing into Buell Frazier’s car, Oswald placed the long package on the back seat. Frazier later said Oswald told him it was curtain rods.
 
When Frazier and Oswald arrived at the Texas School Book Depository parking lot, Oswald grabbed the long package from the back seat and carried it to the depository, staying fifty-feet ahead of Frazier. (Usually, they walked the three-hundred yards together.) 
 
During his interrogation on Friday night, Nov. 22, Oswald said he was having lunch on the first floor of the book depository at the time of the assassination; however, on Sunday morning, Nov. 24, Oswald changed his story, saying that at lunchtime, one of the ‘Negro’ employees invited him to eat lunch with him but he declined, saying, “You go down and send the elevator back up and I will join you in a few minutes.” Oswald said that before he could finish whatever he was doing, the commotion surrounding the assassination took place and he “went downstairs,” where a policeman questioned him as to his identification. Oswald's boss stated he was one of his employees. 
 
Oswald’s statement about being questioned by a policeman shortly after the assassination was a reference to his encounter with Dallas Patrolman M.L. Baker and depository manager Roy S. Truly, who crossed paths with Oswald approximately 90-seconds after the shots in a second-floor lunchroom.
 
Oswald didn’t specify which upper-floor he was on immediately before the assassination. However, a Black depository employee, Charles D. Givens, testified that he returned to the sixth-floor a few minutes before noon to retrieve a pack of cigarettes and encountered Oswald. Givens asked Oswald, “Boy, are you going downstairs? It’s near lunchtime.” Oswald replied, “No, sir. When you get downstairs, close the gate to the elevator,” which would allow Oswald to call the elevator back up remotely.
 
Two weeks after the assassination, the clipboard Oswald had been using on Nov. 22 was found on the sixth-floor behind some cartons in the northwest corner stairwell, near the spot where the rifle was discovered. Three orders for books, which were located on the sixth-floor, were still attached to the clipboard.
 
Consciousness of guilt
 
Oswald lied repeatedly during his interrogation. Here are just a few examples:
 
Oswald denied purchasing or even owning the Mannlicher-Carcano rifle found on the sixth-floor. (Documents in Oswald’s own handwriting prove he ordered the rifle under the alias 'A. Hidell' and had it mailed to a Dallas post-office box he had rented.)
 
Oswald denied that the backyard photograph of him holding the rifle was in fact him. He claimed it was his face superimposed on another person’s body. (Scientific examination later proved that the photographs were genuine and unaltered.)
 
Oswald claimed he had never seen the rifle photograph before. (A copy of one of the photographs, showing Oswald holding the Mannlicher-Carcano, was later found among the effects of Oswald’s friend George DeMohrenschildt, with Oswald’s signature on the back.)
 
Asked by police to reveal all of the addresses he lived at in the past, Oswald provided all of the addresses, except his residence on Neely Street (where the backyard photographs were taken). 
 
Oswald denied telling Buell Wesley Frazier that he went to Irving the night of Nov. 21 to get curtain rods, denied putting a long package in the back of Frazier’s car, and denied carrying a long package into the Depository. (No curtain rods were found in the Depository.)
 
Oswald claimed that the only bag he brought to work on Friday, Nov. 22 was a bag with his lunch in it. (Frazier stated that he noticed that Nov. 22 was the only day that Oswald didn’t bring his lunch and that he thought Oswald planned to buy lunch from the catering truck.)
 
Oswald claimed he was having lunch with James “Junior” Jarman at the time the president was shot. (Jarman testified that he ate alone.)
 
Oswald claimed that he bought the revolver he owned in Fort Worth. (Oswald actually bought the revolver from a Los Angeles mail-order house around the same time he purchased his rifle, using the same alias – A. Hidell.)
 
Finally, Oswald denied having any knowledge of the name ‘A. Hidell,’ the name used to order the weapons that were used to murder President Kennedy and Dallas Patrolman J.D. Tippit, despite the fact that when he was arrested, his wallet contained a false selective service identification card in the name of ‘Alek James Hidell’ which featured Oswald’s photograph. U.S. Postal records showed that Oswald had authorized ‘A.J. Hidell’ to receive mail in his post office box in New Orleans; filling in the ‘Hidell’ name in his own handwriting. When confronted with the form on Sunday, Nov. 24, Oswald denied any knowledge of the contents of the form or any explanation of why he would put the name ‘A.J. Hidell’, which he claimed to have no knowledge about, on the post-office form.
 
Oswald’s actions on November 22 and the lies he told police while in custody betray a “consciousness of guilt” – a type of circumstantial evidence that is used in courtrooms to convince juries of a subject’s guilt. The argument is that the actions and statements of the accused are not how one would expect an innocent person to behave.
 
Oswald’s defenders insist that no one could be that stupid. They figure that there must have been more to it. However, to counter such circumstantial evidence – and the large amount of powerful, supporting, physical evidence – advocates of Oswald’s innocence are burdened with constructing a believable, counter narrative that proves with equally powerful physical evidence that all is not as it seems.
 
So far, after sixty-three years, advocates of Oswald’s innocence have failed to produce the believable, counter narrative – backed with equally powerful physical evidence – that history demands. No doubt, they never will.
 
Aspersions
 
Aspersions have been cast upon Officer J.D. Tippit and the Tippit family for the better part of six decades. Their beloved husband, father, brother, and uncle has been charged with being a racist, a white supremacist, a dirty-cop, a womanizer, and – perhaps, most heinous of all – a conspirator.
 
None of those charges have any basis in fact and those making the accusations couldn’t possibly have anything believable to support them. For many conspiracy advocates, it’s all a parlor game, with zero regard for those who get hurt in the process.
 
And why? What was J.D. Tippit’s crime? 
 
Apparently, being a dedicated police officer and being murdered in the line-of-duty is not reason enough for conspiracy advocates to think before pointing an accusing finger.
 
In the course of the last 28-years, I too have become one of those assailed for daring to defend J.D. Tippit’s devotion-to-family and dedication-to-duty. I’ve been accused of hiding documentary evidence that exonerates Oswald in my book (yes, hiding it in my own book!), withholding vital evidence that proves Oswald innocent, and failing to offer up explanations for every cock-a-mamie scenario that gets suggested by Internet forum posters since my book’s publication.
 
The latest pack of revisionists work hard to ignore the physical evidence, downgrade the eyewitness accounts, and rewrite the long-established narrative with an emphasis on pseudo scenarios that turn the world on its head. None of it is believable to rational people.
 
Perhaps what the revisionists are really so peeved about, and why they generally avoid truthful discussions about the Tippit killing, is that Oswald’s foolish impulse to murder Tippit revealed his need to escape at all costs, and forever doomed any chance for reasonable people to accept their claims of Oswald’s innocence in the Kennedy and Tippit murders.
 
For those deeply devoted to exonerating Oswald for the Tippit murder, I ask only one question: What if you’re wrong?
 
The unprovable
 
Sixty-three years ago today, a dedicated police officer was cut down in the prime of his life by a misguided, Marxist-indoctrinated young man who thought so little of his own life, and those around him, that he was willing to murder in order to show that he was someone to be reckoned with. How sad.
 
The revisionists continue to insist that all is not what it seems. And yet, despite years of endless bickering and reckless allegations, they still have nothing of substance to show us.
 
Unfortunately, their muckraking comes with a steep price – future generations burdened with sorting ludicrous and preposterous fairytales from reality. How can we build a future on American history if we don't know what actually happened? 
 
Expect to see more books, podcasts and educational forum comments in the coming years from revisionist writers who, for ideological reasons, pass off the unbelievable – and especially, the unprovable – as truth. [END]